Obesity-Related Anxiety: A Me-Too Disease?

Psychiatry seems to have a strange fascination with labels.  (I would say it has an obsession with labels, but then it would be labeled OCD.)  We’re so concerned with what we call something that we sometimes ignore the real phenomena staring us in the face every day.

Consider social anxiety disorder (SAD).  Some have argued that this is simply a technical, high-falutin’ label for general shyness, which even “normal” people experience in varying degrees.  There are indeed cases in which someone’s shyness can be horribly incapacitating—and these cases usually benefit from specialized treatment—but there also exists a broad gradient of social anxiety that we all experience.  If I spend too much time worrying about whether the shy patient in my office meets specific criteria for SAD, I might lose sight of why he came to my office in the first place.

So a news story this week caught my eye, with the headline “Obese People Can Suffer From Social Anxiety Due to Weight Alone.”  To a non-psychiatrist, this statement probably seems self-evident: people who are overweight or obese (just like people with any other aspect of their physical appearance that makes them appear “different from normal”) might be anxious or uncomfortable in social settings, simply because of their weight.

This discomfort doesn’t meet criteria for a DSM-IV diagnosis, though.  (At this point, you might ask, but who cares?  Good question—I’ll get to that below.)  The DSM-IV specifies that the symptoms of social anxiety must be unrelated to any medical condition (of which obesity could be considered one).  So if you’re overly self-conscious in social situations due to your weight, or due to an unsightly mole on your face, or due to a psoriasis flare-up, or because you’re a dwarf, sorry, you don’t “qualify” as SAD.

Apparently some researchers want to change this.  In a study to be published this month in the journal Depression and Anxiety, researchers at Brown University and Rhode Island Hospital investigated a large number of obese individuals and found that some of them have social anxiety due to their weight and nothing else, resulting in “greater impairment in social life and greater distress about their social anxiety” than those obese patients who had been diagnosed with (non-obesity-related) SAD earlier in life.  They argue that we should expand the diagnostic criteria in the upcoming DSM-5 to include these folks.  (Indeed, the subtitle of the article in question is “Implications for a Proposed Change in DSM-5.”)

An investigation of their methods, though, reveals that their key finding may have been a foregone conclusion from the start.  Here’s what they did: They interviewed 1,800 people who were being evaluated for weight loss surgery.  (A pre-op comprehensive psychiatric evaluation is often a requirement for bariatric surgery.)  616 people had no psychiatric history whatsoever, while 135 of them had been diagnosed with SAD at some point in their lives.  But then they found 40 additional people whom they labeled as having something they called “modified SAD,” or “clinically significant social anxiety … only related to weight concerns.”  The paper demonstrates that this “modified SAD” group had psychosocial characteristics (like work/social impairment, past/current social functioning, etc) which were strikingly similar to patients with SAD.

But wait a minute… they admit they “labeled” a subset of patients with something that resembled SAD.  So in other words, they pre-selected people with SAD-like symptoms, and then did the analysis to show that, sure enough, they looked like they have SAD!  It’s sort of like taking all the green M&Ms out of a bowl and then performing a series of chemical and physical tests to prove that they are green.  OK, maybe I shouldn’t have used a food analogy, but you get my point…

I don’t mean to be weigh too heavily (no pun intended) on study’s authors (for one thing, the lead author shared a draft of the article with me prior to publication).  I know why articles like this are written; I’m aware that the medical exclusion has made it impossible for us to diagnose SAD in many people who actually have debilitating anxiety due to some obvious cause, like obesity or stuttering.  And this is relevant because we have to give a DSM code in order to be paid for the services we provide.  As with much in life, it’s often all about the money.

But if that’s the only reason we’re squabbling over whether obesity-related anxiety deserves the DSM seal of approval, then I’m sorry, but it’s another example of psychiatrists and psychologists missing the point.  Whether we call something SAD—or depression, or panic disorder, or ADHD, or bipolar disorder, or whatever—means less to the patient than what he or she actually experiences.  Admittedly, we do have to give a “diagnosis” at some point, but we need to ensure our diagnoses don’t become so homogenized that we end up looking at all of our patients through the same lens.

The 40 obese Rhode Islanders who are socially distressed due to their weight probably don’t care whether they’re labeled “SAD,” “modified SAD,” or anythingelse, they just want help.  They want to feel better, and we owe it to them to get our heads out of our DSMs and back into the therapeutic setting where they belong.

Advertisements

25 Responses to Obesity-Related Anxiety: A Me-Too Disease?

  1. leejcaroll says:

    There is too much effort spent trying to pigeonhole people. I understand the payment issue but as a person living with chronic pain I get tired of reading/listening to medical and adjunct medical people trying to get us to fit into their preconceived notions. It is as you say. Often those with chronic pain are disbelieved because pain is subjective; so instead of treating us as individuals with medical complaints we are sent to psychiatrists’ offices where we do not usually fit a DSM Dx. Yes like obese people we are often anxious. They may have a social concern, we have a pain concern but anxiety, as a result, is usually not to a DSM level.
    Carol
    author A PAINED LIFE, a chronic pain journey
    http://apainedlife.blogspot.com/

  2. moviedoc says:

    Much ado about nothing (or barking up the wrong tree):

    First, SAD is seasonal affective disorder. The correct term for what you discuss here is Social Phobia, not social anxiety disorder. The key criterion in DSM is “The individual fears that he or she will act in a way (or show anxiety symptoms) that will be humiliating or embarrassing.” ACT! not look.

    http://behavenet.com/capsules/disorders/socphob.htm

    Exclusionary criteria don’t apply because the criteria don’t apply:

    G. refers to physiological effects, so not applicable here.
    H. refers to ACTION related to a medical condition, not appearance. Again, not applicable.

    For appearance, including obesity, Body Dysmorphic Disorder would seem to apply, and there are NO exclusionary criteria:

    http://behavenet.com/capsules/disorders/bodydysdis.htm

    Better comparisons would be neurofibromatosis, phocomyelia or elephantiasis, or disfiguring injuries like burns or lost limbs.

  3. stevebMD says:

    md, thanks for the details & links — agree that social phobia = social anxiety disorder and the SAD acronym usually refers to seasonal affective d/o. Nevertheless, the article used the term SAD; there must be something more palatable about reading “modified SAD” than “modified SP.”

  4. Having visited many psych professionals for help with my SAD/SP I can really relate to this. In the search for a psychologist to suit my needs I encountered many a label happy counsellor. I was labelled with all sorts of mental health issues before I finally found someone who could look behind the labels and actually help me. Only then did I find out that I had SAD/SP, but like you said that wasn’t the significant part. There is definitely too much effort used trying to label rather than help or treat, good post.

  5. leejcaroll says:

    i have a facial paralysis from medical malpractice. I was embarrassed and upset by how I looked, and worried becauee I was under repeated threat of needing my eye sewn shut because of it.
    In the hospital a psychiatric resident, already well learned in naming regardless of reality, wrote in the chart I had ‘body dysmorphic disorder’ (which as you may know is when you do not have a defect but think you do -oversimplified, I know).
    They learn from the earliest on you need a name no matter what the symptoms (or lack thereof).
    Carol
    http://apainedlife.blogspot.com/

  6. Hey there just wanted to give you a quick heads up. The text in your content seem
    to be running off the screen in Firefox. I’m not sure if this is a format issue or something to do with
    browser compatibility but I figured I’d post to let you know.
    The style and design look great though! Hope you
    get the issue resolved soon. Thanks

  7. The highlight of the camp is the kids get to watch a real surgery being
    performed. , Scitico Plaza in Enfield or visit their website at.

    s needs before deciding to send him or her to a particular camp.
    What should parents look for when choosing soccer camps for kids.
    Camp Akeela 1 Thoreau Way Thetford Center, VT
    05072 Camp Director: Debbie & Eric Sasson Assistant
    Director: Jaynie Goodbody Head Counselor: Jaynie Goodbody & Rob Glyn-Jones.
    ll discover avenues for success that you would never have considered before.
    For example, if you choose “Blake’s Bears” (school or teacher’s name) you could decorate the campground with stuffed bears.
    Every bride wants to look their best on their wedding day, & for most the
    wedding planning will also include loosing weight & toning up
    in vital areas. [5]” These include severe, moderate, and mild forms of Autism Spectrum Disorder (ASD), Social Communication Disorder (SCD), Social Anxiety Disorder (SAD), Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD), Tourette’s Disorder, Fragile X Syndrome (FXS), and Intellectual Development Disorder (IDD). We provide all the best boards and equipment (or you can bring your own) and we’ve got all the things you will need to catch the very best wave that you may.

  8. Summer camp is an experience that enriches lives and all children should have the opportunity to attend kids summer camp.
    Participating in sports activities gives children much more than simply physical benefits.
    Use the following list of basic exercises to get started.
    All Bronze, Silver, and Gold awards are listed as points
    in the profile and here, unless otherwise specified.
    Figure out exactly what you are trying to accomplish with enrollment,
    your child’s skill level, and the experience of the instructors to
    determine the most suitable fit. Commit to the
    actions that say you are what you dream yourself to be.
    These spas provide a way to relax and rejuvenate oneself; while at
    the same time relieve the muscles and stress and
    tension within. When you genuinely mull it over, we really have a choice as for how we react today, and that
    alternative can and will impact our future somewhere down the
    line. Your core muscles are also involved as you brace to
    provide a strong, stable base from which to initiate movement for the rest of the body.
    , spacious outdoor play areas and a climate-controlled indoor environment, Camper
    Cams’.

  9. get off on the very last stop on the route (it costs 6′).
    These divisions of logical grouping enable the kindergarten an alternative of part day schedules if required.

    These friendships are usually extra special because campers
    come from all over the world and they learn to see and respect other children from a different perspective.
    Even with the great shape I got myself in prior to arriving at
    camp, I still had more shape to get into. Here are the usual mix-up of the physical activities that fitness boot camp have for enlistees:
    . If you are new to camping or hiking, you should choose summer as the ideal season for you.
    takes your time out to do some homework
    and do log onto frolicboonies. These boot camps not
    only offer sessions at certain periods through out the year and
    have limited space. Las Vegas boot camp ( will
    not only offer education in getting back to shape, but
    will support you as you embark on that difficult endeavor. , spacious outdoor play areas
    and a climate-controlled indoor environment, Camper Cams’.

  10. The beginning of the end came the day Nia’s boyfriend didn’t take up her offer
    of caring for him when he was ill. It is possible that combining the two hair loss products in a regimen can address the hair loss problem from two fronts.
    Testing blood or saliva usually is done in the morning and evening with the normal ranges as noted below.

  11. An exercise program that suits your body type and requirement will be designed for you.
    Actually, this technique has been utilized for
    thousands of years so when looking at effectiveness, we can’t question them.
    You can have a look at them and then decide whether to
    choose one for you or not.

  12. For those who are looking forward to that perfect tan to match with the dress or the mood or the d.
    As of today, cosmetics and makeup is used or not used by people who want to make a statement one way or the other.

    Another trick to ensure a longer lasting tan is to moisturize your skin with aloe vera or any natural moisturizer.

  13. Most Viewed Mother Son Porn Unique Mom Boy porn Brooke Wylde 1 video
    Kagney Linn Karter She’s Received Big Boobs Pamela hardcore
    sex together with her big boobs p3 Big Boobs Asian Babe Getting Sucked Licked And
    Fucked Exhausting These lesbians are vogue-model quality with a few of the
    best big boobs on this website! Haley’s big
    tits nearly defy gravity! This free tube presents
    the hottest free busty girlfriends porn videos we could find on the web.
    We all love the busty ladies and now there all here in one place, only for you.
    Big boobs truthful haired slutty whore satisfies Curvaceous mom with juicy
    jugs takes huge dong Insatiable breath taking Asian bitch with large Big Tits
    On ImLive Click below to talk with these busty babes Kate Upton Complains
    About Her Big Boobs Younger ladies boobs 15451 clips) Anal porn

  14. My partner and I stumbled over here from a different
    page and thought I might as well check things out. I like what I see so now i am following you.
    Look forward to looking over your web page yet again.

  15. When someone writes an piece of writing he/she retains the thought of a user in his/her mind that how a user can understand
    it. So that’s why this article is amazing.
    Thanks!

  16. Mokhlesi B, Morris AL, Huang CF, Curcio AJ,
    Barrett TA, Kamp DW: Elevated prevalence of gastroesophageal reflux symptoms
    in patients with COPD.

  17. The sodium bicarbonate is taken again into the blood and tissues to buffer metabolic,
    respiratory and environmental acids or deposited into
    the salivary glands, stomach glands, pancreas or intestinal glands to buffer dietary and
    gastrointestinal acids.

  18. Patients with nonsurgical esophageal most cancers
    who have an estimated life expectancy of larger than a number of weeks are really helpful to have
    concurrent chemoradiotherapy as most patients have symptomatic obstructive illness and dysphagia
    62. A examine by Harvey et al examined the palliative good
    thing about chemoradiotherapy on dysphagia versus toxicity in patients with invasive
    esophageal carcinoma 75. The research discovered that
    remedy was well tolerated, with only 5% of patients failing to complete treatment.

  19. The following part will try to reply common questions that sufferers will
    ask in clinic, and clarify extra fully precisely
    how acid reflux disease is caused, the connection between acid reflux disease and hiatus
    hernia, what Barrett’s oesophagus is and the best treatment
    options for acid reflux disease. The good news about acid
    reflux disease disease is that whether it is investigated appropriately and recognized accurately, then there are extremely good remedy choices each by drug
    therapy or secure surgical procedure. Subsequently if reflux signs are currently an issue, you will be reassured that soon it is possible for you to to return to a normal way
    of life. Acid reflux illness is induced when stomach contents (acid and bile) reflux upwards previous a weakened sphincter (valve mechanism)
    into the decrease gullet.

  20. Eosinophils are major immune cells concerned in allergic reactions.

  21. Milan says:

    This process is lined by some personal well being insurers.

  22. He is a Medical Professor (retired) within the Division of Emergency Medicine,
    UT Health Science Heart at San Antonio, and has been the Chief of Emergency Medicine at UT
    Medical Department and at UTHSCSA with over 250 publications.

  23. Consultez régulièrement à nous dépôt parmi strie Oxyo-pneumatique.fr, auprès découvrir certain semaine à nous dernières proposition de
    réduction, valables sur manifeste milliers en tenant boyau neufs sur notre condition.
    N’hésitez foulée à consulter également cette écriture Promo à l’égard de notre emplacement
    internet puis profitez ainsi à l’égard de remises exceptionnelles sur fondés centaines en même
    temps que pneumatique foulée chers. Alors surtout, n’oubliez marche, auprès
    terminé achat sur Oxyo-boyau.fr, votre commande vous-même sera livrée en toi-même ou bien dans l’bizarre de nos 3800 délai partenaires puis constamment gratuitement.

  24. Dre Beats says:

    Hi there it’s me, I am also visiting this website
    daily, this website is in fact nice and the visitors are truly sharing pleasant thoughts.

  25. Lauri says:

    You share interesting articles here. I think that your blog can go viral easily and i know how to
    do it, just type in google – omgerido traffic tips

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: